Former players Indy Eleven
Oluwatobiloba Abraham Adewole  |  Fredrick Amass Amankona  |  Lamine Baldé  |  Nicolás José Barrera  |  Patrick John Barrett  |  Brian Brown  |  Andrew Benjamin Conner  |  Paulo Morais de Araújo Júnior  |  Jordan Patrick Dear Hamilton  |  Almamy Diaby  |  Eric William Dick  |  Liam Daniel Doyle  |  Colin Falvey  |  Reiner Ferreira Correa Gomes  |  Pedro Ferreira Mendes  |  Marco Antonio Franco  |  Carl Haworth  |  Kyle Robert Hyland  |  Dane Kelly  |  Aidan Bardina Liu  |  Nedeljko Malić  |  Anthony Manning  |  Judson McKinney  |  Vincent Mitchell  |  Dane O'Brian Richards  |  Oghenefejiro Okiomah  |  Lovel Alphanso Palmer  |  Tyler Geoffrey Pasher  |  Nicholas Stephen Paterson  |  Victor Pineda  |  Cristian Portilla Rodríguez  |  Bradford Evan Rusin  |  Hassan Ali Saad  |  Benjamin Shields Lundgaard  |  Donald Leroy Smart  |  Blake Smith  |  Benjamin Fritz Spencer Jr.  |  Zachary Wolfgang Steinberger  |  Dragan Stojkov  |  Tanner Joseph Thompson  |  Aaron Vargha Hooper  |  Travis Wannemuehler  |  Gordon Wild  |  Éamon Zayed